Jesus said:
If another member of the church sins against you, go and point out the fault when the two of you are alone. If the member listens to you, you have regained that one. But if you are not listened to, take one or two others along with you, so that every word may be confirmed by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If the member refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if the offender refuses to listen even to the church, let such a one be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. Again, truly I tell you, if two of you agree on earth about anything you ask, it will be done for you by my Father in heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them. (Mt. 18:15-20, NRSV).
This passage is actually set in the context of wounding and healing, condemning and restoring. A lot of responsibility resides in that group of two or three people, especially when we’re gathering in the name of Christ. The tongue is a powerful thing. It has the power to cut or cleanse.
Allow me to set the stage….
A youth group from another church in our conference was coming to our city for a special youth event and requested to spend the night at our church. I said, “of course.” I then asked our office manager if she would call the chair of our men’s group to see if they would bump their breakfast by one week so that they, out of the kindness of their hearts, could also cook for these twenty-five youth and their adult leaders. My office manager said they said, “yes.”
The week before the youth were scheduled to come, I called our men’s group leader to confirm the time. He thought we had asked the men’s group to move their breakfast so as not to conflict with the youth group. How did this happen? I clarified my hopes. Although he had had a really rough week at work (which I later learned), he said that it shouldn’t be a problem. He really is a saint.
Our resident men’s group chef and our leader arrived at 5:30am to begin cooking for a 7am breakfast. Within minutes of starting the gas stove, the fire alarm went off. The fire alarm is not particularly loud, but it does put off a particularly high and screeching pitch. Surprisingly enough, the boys on the third floor slept through it and through the screams of the girls. The girls sleeping near the elevator on the second floor (where the alarm speakers are positioned) did not.
The men figured out how to override the fire alarm.
When I arrived at 6am the lights were on. Everybody was up and getting ready.
Our resident chef concocted biscuits and gravy. As he stood stirring the gravy forever in this giant pot, waiting for it to thicken, I explained that I admire anyone who can cook. I usually somehow manage to ruin every pan I touch, even non-stick ones. He said, “Oh really? That’s too bad.”
Breakfast was served. Thirty minutes passed before the rest of the men’s group were to arrive. The pot of gravy was placed back on the stove for warming.
Everyone ate. The dishes were washed, all except the big pot in which the gravy had been cooked. It was filled with murky, sudsy water. Our resident chef and resident dishwasher agreed that the pot should soak overnight. One of them would wash it in the morning.
Sunday morning came and went.
Sunday evening I came back in for our own youth event. I entered the kitchen to begin washing plates from our pizza dinner. I discovered the pot still sitting in the sink. As I dumped the water out to begin washing it, I noticed black stuff still charred to the bottom of the pot. It was not coming off. Suddenly a string of thoughts began to flow….
I think this pot is ruined.
Is this the Bazaar ladies’ pot? The same pot they bought with their hard-earned fund-raising money, voted upon, and elected, after some debate, to buy?
Did any of the Bazaar ladies see their pot, unwashed, in the sink, with black stuff charred to the bottom?
I began to tend to the black stuff charred to the bottom of the pot. This situation looked eerily familiar. I was pretty sure this pot was ruined.
The reeling and somewhat panicked thoughts in my head radiated through my arms and hands. I gave all the elbow grease I could to that pot, with little tender, loving care. I got most of the black stuff out, but I’m still not convinced the pot is okay. But here’s the deal. With a youth and three youth workers standing near by, I let my thoughts begin to wander out of my mouth….
Me: I sure hope this isn’t the Bazaar ladies’ pot.
Lesson #1: Speculation is never helpful.
Youth Worker 1: There is a Bazaar ladies’ pot?
Me: Well, I mean, I think this was their investment. I think this pot was an intentional purchase. I think a vote and some emotional debate went into this pot.
Lesson #2: Sharing second-hand information, especially information that was probably not even correctly remembered by me, is not helpful.
Youth Worker 1: That’s ridiculous. They should put their name on it then.
Me (trying to clarify): I don’t even know if this is the pot. I just hope nobody saw it. Maybe we can still get it clean.
By this point I was feeling guilty. Guilty about my comment the previous morning that I always ruin pots (like I jinxed him or something). Guilty for committing the men to all this extra, last-minute work in cooking for twenty-five extra people (although it was so well-received and they got lots of cool points for it). Most of all, guilty for saying what I was thinking out loud. I wish I had just stopped talking. It only got worse from there.
Youth Worker 2 (who is also in the men’s group): Is that pot from the men’s breakfast yesterday? Why didn’t we clean it?
Me (trying to defend): It was really hard to clean, so they resolved to soak it overnight. I guess they forgot about it this morning.
Youth Worker 2: So we just put off the problem.
Me (still defending, gah!): No, it was just really bad. I think they just forgot this morning. I just hope none of the Bazaar ladies saw it.
Youth Worker 2: Maybe the men just need to buy their own pot then. Then we’ll label them “Men’s pot” and “Bazaar ladies’ pot.”
Somehow the word “crankies” entered into the conversation about this time. I sure hope it wasn’t me.
Me (trying to justify): Every church has its “crankies.” I know we have our share, but they don’t seem to have as much influence here as they do in other churches I’ve been in. Well…. for the most part.
Believe it or not, this was meant as a compliment.
The conversation was going downhill fast. Youth Worker 2 changed the subject. I was so glad.
I am just sitting here, the next day, wondering what kind of backlash is going to come out of this conversation, especially with three adults and a youth in the room. A youth whose grandmother, whom I really love, is one of the Bazaar ladies, and whose grandfather is the men’s group leader. These things never get communicated well.
Lesson #3: If you think there is a problem go directly to the source.
Instead of letting my big mouth wander, I should have communicated directly with the men’s group leader, his wife from the Bazaar group, and established #1.) whether there was even a problem, and #2.) how I could help remedy the problem. Now I have three adults and a youth who think our Bazaar ladies are a bunch of “crankies” (and they’re not at all, they’re actually a lot of fun), and I was the culprit of the conversation.
At this point I can only beg for forgiveness while I try to learn a lesson from all of this. Nobody said or did anything to deserve all these negative vibes. It all boiled down to me and my big mouth, stirring the proverbial pot.
This reminds me of a mentor and pastor who once said to our group, “I have to remember that the church is the bride of Christ, and any time I have anything bad to say about the church, I am “discing” Christ’s bride. Jesus can’t possibly appreciate that.”
And what kind of message about our church, our mission, and our vision, have I sent to four members of our church after a speculative and useless conversation?
I’m reminded of the famous words of Thumper in the movie, Bambi:
“If you can’t say somethin’ nice, don’t say nothin’ at all.”
Especially when we’re gathered in the name of Christ.